Top Places To Eat On Fire Island, Long Island – Best Fire Island Restaurants To Visit

These Fire Island restaurants are all great options for your next trip to the Long Island hot spot. If you are looking for suggestions from a local, you’ve found a handful of places that will satisfy your family’s ever-curious palette. 

fire island restaurants

This island is a summer go-to destination for the New York metro area. This beautiful barrier island has become a haven for those who need a quaint and quiet getaway from the city, without a lot of travel time.

As with any tourist destination, there are plentiful options for food all over the island. In fact, it might be tough to make up your mind just which of the places to eat on Fire Island, Long Island is calling to you.

Fire Island Restaurants

While we can’t tell you what you’re in the mood for, we’ve gathered up some delicious tips to help you find the best Fire Island restaurants while you’re visiting this summertime staple. Fresh food, amazing atmosphere, and incredible locals – these hot spots are hard to beat. 

The Best Fire Island Restaurants To Visit

Rachel's Bakery Fire Island

Rachel’s Bakery & Restaurant – For more than 40 years, Rachel’s Bakery has provided visitors to Fire Island with delicious baked goods and breakfast items, later expanding to a full restaurant. Whether you want some delicious pastries to eat on the go or a full sit-down breakfast, you won’t be disappointed!

Floyd’s – For a quick breakfast and a cup of coffee, Floyd’s is a local favorite. This is a simple, counter service stop that has easy options like their famous breakfast sandwiches, omelets, french toast, and breakfast burritos. Definitely, a don’t-miss for a quick morning bite!

The Landing at Ocean Beach – The Landing at Ocean Beach has everything you want in a sit-down breakfast restaurant. Enjoy their eggs benedict, a delicious frittata, a classic breakfast of eggs and sausage, and more as you take stunning waterfront views. We couldn’t create a round-up on the best Fire Island restaurants without including this one. 

Casual Food on Fire Island 

Carts In a Row Fire Island on Long Island

Surf’s Out – With a great kids menu and loads of delicious choices for seafood lovers and those who aren’t fans of the fruits of the sea, Surf’s Out is a perfect choice for lunch or dinner. And a bonus? They offer online ordering for takeout! Add this to your Fire Island restaurants list for sure. 

Nicky’s Clam Bar – Nicky’s Clam Bar has loads of choices from seafood to burgers and everything in between. They have a fun kids menu with a variety of choices, plus a takeout window that makes it easy to grab lunch and go. Plus, they’re located in the ferry marina, convenient on your way on or off the island. 

Cherry Grove Pizza – Grab a slice, pick up a specialty pizza, or enjoy pasta or a sandwich at Cherry Grove Pizza. The whole family will find something they love on the menu! Sit down and enjoy a great lunch or dinner or place an order for pickup or delivery. 

Sit-Down Meals on Fire Island – Best Fire Island Restaurants 

Matthew’s Seafood House – It’s always a good sign when a seafood restaurant features their own market. Matthew’s offers delicious, fresh seafood options in a variety of cooking styles. Matthew’s has been a Fire Island staple since 1974! You know that we love this kind of option. A must add to your Fire Island Restaurants list. 

Le Dock  – If you’re looking for a dinner that is a little more upscale for a wonderful date night, Le Dock, by Jean-Georges Vongerichten, is the place to go on Fire Island. Enjoy local seafood as well as traditional dinner fare with a waterside atmosphere. 

Maguire’s – At Maguire’s, the whole family can enjoy a fantastic sit-down meal of seafood, steak, and other favorites. Plus, the kids can burn off a little energy at the playground situated right next to the restaurant. Be sure to check out their Lobsterpalooza on Thursdays and watch for other great weeknight specials!

fire island restaurants

Where do you get the ferry to Fire Island?

Fire Island is served by the Sayville Ferry, which is located on River Road in the South Shore hamlet of Sayville. 41 River Road Sayville, NY 11782-0626

Who owns Flynn’s Fire Island?

Flynn’s Fire Island, located on 1 Cayuga Street in Ocean Bay Park, has been owned and operated by the Flynn family for five generations. 

How many towns are in Fire Island?

There are 17 towns in Fire Island.

  • Kismet
  • Saltaire
  • Fair Harbor
  • Dunewood
  • Lonelyville
  • Atlantique
  • Robbins Rest
  • Corneille Estates
  • Ocean Beach Village
  • Seaview
  • Ocean Bay Park
  • Point O’Woods
  • Cherry Grove
  • Fire Island Pines
  • Water Island
  • Davis Park
  • Watch Hill

Is there a bathroom on the Fire Island Ferry?

No, there are no bathrooms on the boats. There are bathrooms at the ferry terminal in Bay Shore. 

Have you been to this part of Long Island? What is your favorite place to eat? Do you agree with this list of Best Fire Island restaurants? What names would you like to add to this list?

Want more coverage about Fire Island, Long Island?

About Me


Check out Vera Sweeney's media kit here.

Subscribe to Lady and the Blog

Looking for weekly updates? Want to receive every recipe, free printable, and contest notification? I would love to have you part of my newsletter community.

.

Recipes You Need to Make