Skip to Content

Long Island Thrift Stores – A Comprehensive List

If you’re on Long Island and love a good deal, check out this list of local thrift stores in both Nassau and Suffolk. They’re not just shops – they’re like mini treasure hunts. You can score anything from cool vintage clothes to funky furniture, and it’s all super affordable.

Shopping at these places is a win-win; you save money while repurchasing items that would have just ended up in some landfill if thrown away. And the best part? Your money often goes to local charities, so you’re doing good while you shop. Whether you’re in the Hamptons or closer to the city, Long Island’s thrift scene is full of surprises and great finds. So, get out there and see what you can discover!

nassau couny thrift store

Thrift Stores Located In Nassau, Long Island

Here is a list of 10 thrift stores in Nassau County, Long Island, along with their contact information and websites where available:

  1. Garden City Thrift Store
    • Address: 2160 Jericho Turnpike, Garden City Park, NY 11040
    • Contact: 516.746.8250
    • Website: Not available​​.
  2. My Unique Thrift Westbury
  3. Paper Doll Vintage Boutique
  4. Hidden Treasures Thrift Shop
  5. The Huntington Store
  6. Finder’s Keepers
  7. Second Time Around
  8. Deep End of the Sandbox
  9. Antique Attics
  10. MyUnique in Levittown
    • Location: Levittown, NY
    • Description: A large store with various departments and a flea market, offering clothes, shoes, and more.
    • Website: Not specified​​.

These stores offer a range of products, from clothing and shoes to furniture, household items, and antiques, catering to various tastes and needs. Please visit their websites or contact them directly for more detailed information, including exact locations and operating hours.

hamptons thrift store

Hamptons Thrift Store Locations

Here are some thrift store locations in the Hamptons, offering a range of unique and interesting items for shoppers:

  1. Ava’s & Around Again
    • Location: Long Wharf, Sag Harbor, NY
    • Features: A consignment and vintage store known for its eclectic collection of consigned clothing, accessories, and vintage treasures, offering a mix of contemporary and vintage items​​.
  2. Thriftknd
    • Location: 76 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY
    • Features: A vibrant consignment and vintage clothing store with a colorful and playful ambiance, featuring an eclectic mix of retro prints, bold patterns, and timeless classics​​.
  3. Le Closet
    • Location: 9 Windmill Lane, Southampton, NY
    • Features: Offers a curated collection of high-end fashion combining luxury with sustainability, including designer clothing and accessories from prestigious fashion houses​​.
  4. ARF Thrift & Treasure Shop
    • Location: 17 Poxabogue Lane, Sagaponack, NY
    • Features: Part of the Animal Rescue Fund of the Hamptons, this shop offers a unique shopping experience with a collection of gently used accessories, furniture, household items, and more​​.
  5. LVIS Bargain Box Thrift Shop
    • Location: 95 Main St, East Hampton, NY
    • Features: Operated by the Ladies’ Village Improvement Society, this shop has been a community staple for over 100 years, offering a diverse selection of gently used items including clothing, accessories, furniture, and books​​.
  6. The Retreat Boutique
    • Location: 2102 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton, NY
    • Features: Operated by The Retreat, a nonprofit organization supporting victims of domestic violence, this boutique offers a curated collection of designer and high-end clothing, accessories, and home decor items​​.

These stores not only provide a great opportunity for finding unique and affordable items but also often support charitable causes, making them worthwhile destinations for both shopping and community contribution.

goodwill long island

Goodwill Locations on Long Island

Here are some Goodwill store locations on Long Island and their contact information.

  1. Goodwill Store – Ronkonkoma
    • Address: 585 Portion Rd, Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
    • Contact: (631) 588-3801
    • Website: www.goodwill.org.
  2. Goodwill Store – Carle Place
    • Address: 151 Voice Rd, Carle Place, NY 11514
    • Contact: (516) 877-7200
    • Website: www.goodwillnynj.org.
  3. Goodwill Store of Massapequa
    • Address: 814 Hicksville Rd, Massapequa, NY 11758
    • Contact: (516) 795-0237
    • Website: www.goodwillnynj.org
    • Hours:
      • Mon: Closed
      • Tue-Sat: 9:00 am – 9:00 pm
      • Sun: 10:00 am – 8:00 pm.
  4. Goodwill Stores – North Massapequa
    • Address: 814 Hicksville Rd, North Massapequa, NY 11758
    • Contact: (516) 795-0237
    • Website: www.goodwillnynj.org.
  5. Goodwill Mini Shop & Donation Drop – Syosset
    • Address: 1163 Merrick Ave, Syosset, NY 11791
    • Contact: (516) 206-3984
    • Website: www.goodwillnynj.org.
  6. Goodwill Glasses – Port Washington
    • Address: 73 Country Club Dr, Port Washington, NY 11050
    • Contact: (516) 439-4807.
  7. Goodwill Career Center and Donation – Port Washington
    • Address: 25 Old Shore Rd, Port Washington, NY 11050
    • Contact: (203) 983-7340
    • Website: goodwill.org.
  8. Goodwill Donation Center
    • Address: 1212 E Putnam Ave, Stamford, CT 06902
    • Contact: (203) 983-7340
    • Website: www.gwct.org.

For the most accurate and up-to-date information, I recommend contacting the stores directly or visiting their websites.

consignment shop

What are items one can expect to find at a consignment shop?

At a consignment shop, you can generally find a variety of second-hand items. Thrift shopping is always a unique experience. The sales floor is the perfect place to be surprised and wowed! You might come across vintage items being sold at good prices, items from estate sales, designer clothing, and household goods. Let’s breakdown in detail what hidden gem pieces you might come across:

  1. Clothing and Accessories: Many consignment shops offer a wide range of pre-owned clothing for men, women, and children. This includes everyday wear, formal attire, vintage pieces, designer labels, seasonal outfits, and various accessories like handbags, belts, hats, and scarves.
  2. Jewelry: From costume jewelry to sometimes finer pieces, consignment shops often have a selection of rings, necklaces, bracelets, earrings, and watches.
  3. Furniture: Depending on the size and focus of the shop, you might find furniture such as chairs, tables, shelves, dressers, and decorative items. These home decor items can range from modern to antique styles.
  4. Home Décor and Art: Items like paintings, prints, vases, lamps, rugs, and other decorative pieces are commonly found. These items can add character and style to a home.
  5. Books and Media: Some consignment shops offer used books, DVDs, CDs, vinyl records, and sometimes vintage or collectible media items.
  6. Toys and Games: Especially in shops that focus on children’s items, you can find a variety of toys, games, and possibly baby gear.
  7. Sporting Goods and Equipment: This can include sports gear, fitness equipment, bicycles, and outdoor recreational items.
  8. Electronics: While not as common, some consignment shops may offer electronic items like cameras, audio equipment, and occasionally computers or tablets.
  9. Specialty Items: Depending on the shop, you might find unique or niche items such as collectibles, antiques, musical instruments, or crafting supplies.

Remember, consignment shops typically sell items on behalf of individuals, who then receive a portion of the sale price. The quality and selection of items can vary greatly depending on the store’s policies, the local area, and the current inventory. It’s always a bit of a treasure hunt, as the stock in these shops changes regularly.

home goods

Is Home Goods considered a thrift shop?

No, HomeGoods is not considered a thrift shop. HomeGoods is a retail chain that sells new, off-price home décor and furniture. It’s part of TJX Companies, which also owns other off-price retail stores like T.J. Maxx and Marshalls.

The key differences between HomeGoods and a thrift shop are:

  1. Product Source: HomeGoods sources its products directly from manufacturers, often overstock or last season’s items from various brands. In contrast, thrift shops typically sell used items donated or consigned by individuals.
  2. Item Condition: At HomeGoods, the items are new, though they might be from past seasons or overstock. Thrift shops primarily sell second-hand goods, which can range from like-new to well-worn condition.
  3. Pricing and Business Model: HomeGoods operates on an off-price retail model, offering new goods at discounted prices. Thrift shops usually sell donated or consigned goods at lower prices, and often, part of their proceeds may support charitable causes.
  4. Inventory: HomeGoods’ inventory includes a wide range of home furnishings, décor, kitchenware, bedding, and more. The store curates the selection and tends to be more consistent in style and quality. Thrift shops have a more eclectic and unpredictable inventory, depending on what items have been donated or consigned.

So, while both HomeGoods and thrift shops offer items at reduced prices, their business models, product sources, and the condition of their goods are quite different.

thrifting

Where is the Junior League of Long Island thrift shop?

The Junior League of Long Island Thrift Shop is located in Roslyn, New York. It is a great store for vintage clothing, a wonderful assortment of jewelry and is known for their friendly staff. Thanks to the generous neighbors of Rosyln, this location is always packed with incredible finds. Expect a great selection at an affordable price. Here are the details:

  • Address: 1395 Old Northern Blvd, Roslyn, NY 11576
  • Contact: (516) 621-4890

The thrift shop has been a significant part of the Roslyn village community since 1951 and serves as a major fundraiser supporting the Junior League’s programming in the Long Island community.

Where is the NCJW thrift shop?

The NCJW (National Council of Jewish Women) Thrift Shop is located in Lawrence, New York. Here are the details:

  • Address: 342 Central Avenue, Lawrence, NY 11559
  • Contact Number: 516.569.0510
  • Email Address: thriftshopncjw@optonline.net
  • Description: The NCJW Thrift Shop is one of the largest upscale resale shops on Long Island, offering a wide range of items including furniture, artwork, clothing for men, women, and children, housewares, linens, bric-a-brac, electronics, shoes, purses, jewelry, and seasonal merchandise.
flea market

How are thrift stores different than flea markets?

Thrift stores and flea markets are both popular for finding unique items and bargains, but they operate quite differently and offer distinct shopping experiences:

  1. Ownership and Operation:
    • Thrift Stores: These are usually fixed retail locations operated by a single entity, which could be a charity, non-profit organization, or a private business. The store sells items that have been donated or sometimes consigned.
    • Flea Markets: A flea market is typically a larger, open space where multiple vendors set up temporary stalls or booths. These vendors can be a mix of private individuals and small business owners selling a variety of new and used goods.
  2. Type of Goods Sold:
    • Thrift Stores: Generally sell second-hand items, including clothing, books, furniture, and household items. The quality and condition of items can vary, but they are often curated to some degree by the store’s staff.
    • Flea Markets: Offer a wider range of items, including antiques, collectibles, vintage items, handmade crafts, and sometimes new goods. The variety is broader because each vendor decides what to sell.
  3. Pricing:
    • Thrift Stores: Prices at thrift stores are usually set by the store and tend to be relatively low, as the items are mostly donated.
    • Flea Markets: Pricing can vary widely depending on the vendor and the type of goods. Haggling over prices is more common and accepted in flea markets.
  4. Atmosphere and Experience:
    • Thrift Stores: Offer a more traditional retail experience, with items displayed in a store setting. Shopping is generally more predictable with consistent hours and location.
    • Flea Markets: Provide a more dynamic and varied experience. They are often held outdoors or in large open spaces and might only operate on certain days of the week or month. Flea markets can have a lively atmosphere with food vendors and a wide range of items to explore.
  5. Purpose and Community Impact:
    • Thrift Stores: Many thrift stores are affiliated with charitable organizations, and sales proceeds often support various social causes.
    • Flea Markets: While some flea markets may have a community or charity focus, most are commercial ventures for individual vendors.

While thrift and flea markets are great for finding unique items at lower prices, thrift stores offer a more traditional and consistent shopping experience focusing on second-hand goods, often supporting charitable causes. Flea markets, however, provide a diverse and dynamic marketplace with a wide range of vendors and goods, including antiques, collectibles, and sometimes new products.

The best thrift shops on Long Island are often filled with unique finds at reasonable prices. Be sure to bring your shopping bag and prepare to become a reuse champion. 

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.